Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


How to amend a carried-over budget motion at the next meeting

Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


At our October guild meeting, the budget committee presented the 2027 budget. An amendment was made by a member and passed that raised the Program Budget from $14,500 to $20,000. The motion was approved. The budget was left pending until our November meeting. The budget committee now recommends keeping $14,500 in the Program Budget and creating a separate line item for the additional $5,500 as "Special Programs." This would still ultimately give $20,000 for programs. How should this be presented — as a new motion, a revision, or something else?

Handling the Pending Budget at the Next Meeting

The Key Procedural Issue

Since the budget motion was left pending from the previous meeting, it carries over to the next meeting exactly as it stood when the meeting adjourned — meaning the already-amended version with $20,000 in Program Budget is what's pending. This shapes what options are available.


Recommended Approach: Move to Amend

The cleanest solution is for the budget committee (or any member) to move a new amendment to the pending motion that restructures the line items while keeping the total intact.

The Motion Would Read:

*"I move to amend the pending budget motion by reducing the Program Budget line item from $20,000 to $14,500 and adding a new line item titled 'Special Programs' in the amount of $5,500."

Why This Works:
  • It respects the previous amendment's intent (total program funding = $20,000) ✓
  • It achieves the committee's structural recommendation ✓
  • It is germane to the pending budget motion ✓
  • It requires only a majority vote to pass

Alternative: Substitute Amendment

If the changes are more extensive, the committee could move to substitute a revised budget document for the pending one:

"I move to substitute the following revised budget for the pending budget motion..."

This also requires a majority vote.


Important Notes

Factor Details
Vote required Majority (simple)
Debatable? Yes
Who can make the motion? Any member, though the committee chair presenting it adds credibility
Chair's role Should clearly state what is pending before new amendments are offered

Suggested Meeting Flow

  1. Chair announces the budget motion is carried over from the previous meeting and states it as it currently reads (with $20,000 in Program Budget)
  2. Committee chair presents the recommendation and moves the amendment
  3. Amendment is seconded
  4. Debate occurs
  5. Vote on the amendment
  6. If passed, vote on the main motion (the budget as amended)

Bottom line: No need for a brand-new main motion — a simple amendment to the pending motion is the proper and most efficient path.

Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions