How the committee of the whole works under Robert's Rules
Asked November 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
What are the rules for a committee of the whole?
Committee of the Whole
A committee of the whole is a procedure where the entire assembly transforms itself into a committee temporarily, allowing for freer and more informal discussion before the assembly takes formal action.
When It's Used
This procedure is typically employed when:
- The assembly wants more relaxed, open discussion than formal rules allow
- The body is large and benefits from a less structured debate environment
- Members want to explore a topic thoroughly before committing to a formal vote
How It Works — Step by Step
-
A member makes a motion to go into committee of the whole. This requires a second and a majority vote to adopt.
-
The chair steps aside. The presiding officer appoints a chair to lead the committee (or vacates the chair), since the committee of the whole operates separately from the formal assembly.
-
Discussion proceeds under relaxed rules — debate is generally freer and less constrained than in the regular assembly.
-
The committee "rises and reports." When discussion is complete, the committee formally ends its session and reports its findings or recommendations back to the assembly.
-
The assembly takes formal action on whatever the committee has recommended. The regular presiding officer resumes the chair at this point.
Key Characteristics
- What happens in committee of the whole is generally not reflected in the formal minutes in the same detail as regular assembly proceedings — only the committee's final report to the assembly is recorded.
- The relaxed atmosphere allows members to speak more freely and more than once on the same question.
- The committee itself cannot take final action — it can only make recommendations for the full assembly to act upon.