How soon can a defeated bylaw amendment be brought up for a vote again
Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
A bylaw amendment was voted down by the membership of a nonprofit organization. When and how can the amendment be brought up for a vote a second time?
Reconsidering a Failed Bylaw Amendment
Short Answer
A defeated bylaw amendment cannot be immediately reconsidered and must wait before it can be brought up again. The specific timing depends on your bylaws and applicable rules.
Standard Rules Under Robert's Rules
Option 1: Wait Until the Next Session
The most straightforward path is to reintroduce the amendment at a future meeting or session. Once a motion has been voted down in a session, it generally cannot be brought back during that same session except through a Motion to Reconsider.
Option 2: Motion to Reconsider (Same Session Only)
- Must be made during the same session it was voted on
- Can only be moved by a member who voted on the prevailing side (i.e., someone who voted "No")
- Requires a majority vote to pass
- If successful, the amendment is back before the assembly for debate and a new vote
Important Bylaw Consideration
Most nonprofit bylaws include specific provisions for how and when bylaw amendments may be proposed, such as:
- Required advance notice (e.g., 30–60 days before the meeting)
- Minimum time between attempts
- Required vote threshold (commonly 2/3 vote)
⚠️ Check your bylaws first. Your organization's own rules govern this process and take precedence over Robert's Rules defaults.
Practical Steps to Reintroduce the Amendment
- Review your bylaws for amendment procedures and any waiting periods
- Provide required advance notice to the membership per your bylaws
- Submit the amendment through whatever process your bylaws prescribe
- Schedule it on the agenda for the appropriate future meeting
- The assembly debates and votes again — there is no limit on how many times an amendment may be reintroduced in future sessions
Key Point
Under Robert's Rules, there is no prohibition on reintroducing the same amendment at a later session — the slate is essentially wiped clean once a new session begins. The amendment can be brought back exactly as before, or in modified form, as many times as the membership wishes to try.