Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


How should bylaws be updated when an amendment is adopted with a proviso

Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


When the secretary updates the bylaws after amendments are adopted with a proviso, should the secretary keep the current language in the bylaws and also add the new language alongside it?

Updating Bylaws After Amendment with a Proviso

No — the secretary should not keep both the old and new language in the bylaws text itself. The bylaws document should reflect only the newly amended language, even when a proviso is attached.


What a Proviso Does

A proviso is a condition attached to a bylaws amendment that modifies how or when the amendment takes effect — not whether it takes effect. Common examples:

  • "...provided that this amendment shall not affect officers currently serving"
  • "...provided that this amendment takes effect at the conclusion of the annual meeting"

The proviso governs the transition or application of the new rule, but the new language is still the operative bylaw going forward.


What the Secretary Should Do
  1. Update the bylaws text to reflect the newly adopted language
  2. Record the proviso separately — typically in the minutes of the meeting where the amendment was adopted
  3. Consider a footnote in the bylaws document referencing the proviso and citing the meeting where it was adopted, so future readers understand any transitional conditions
  4. Ensure the certificate of amendment or amendment record notes the proviso

Why This Matters

The proviso is temporary in nature — it addresses a transitional circumstance. Once that circumstance has passed, the proviso is no longer operative. Embedding both old and new language in the bylaws would create confusion about what the current rule actually is.


Key Takeaway

The bylaws should always reflect the current governing rules. The historical record (minutes, amendment logs) is the proper place to preserve the context of how and when a change took effect.

Robert's Rules addresses bylaw amendment procedures in **, and minutes requirements in **.

Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions