How does a board handle a tie vote under Robert's Rules
Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
How does a board handle a tie vote procedurally?
Handling a Tie Vote in Parliamentary Procedure
The Basic Rule
A tie vote is a failed vote. Under Robert's Rules, a motion requires a majority of votes cast to pass. Since a tie means equal votes for and against, the motion does not achieve a majority and therefore fails.
Under Robert's Rules, a majority vote means more than half of the votes cast.
Step-by-Step: What the Chair Does
- Announce the vote count — "The vote is 4 in favor, 4 opposed"
- Declare the result — "The motion fails for lack of a majority"
- State the effect — "The motion is lost"
The Chair's Vote in a Tie
The chair may choose to vote to break (or create) a tie, but only under specific conditions:
| Situation | Chair's Option |
|---|---|
| Voting is by ballot | Chair votes along with everyone else |
| Voting is by voice or show of hands | Chair may cast a deciding vote |
| Chair wants to break the tie | Votes YES to pass the motion |
| Chair wants to create a tie (to defeat) | Votes NO to cause failure |
The chair is never required to vote and typically abstains to preserve impartiality.
After a Tie — Options Available
Once a motion fails on a tie, the assembly may:
- Move to Reconsider — if a member who voted on the prevailing side wishes to bring it back
- Renew the motion — at a future meeting
- Move to Rescind — if action was previously taken and needs to be undone
- Simply move on to the next item of business
Important Caveat: Appeals
If the chair's ruling results in a tie on an Appeal motion, the tie actually sustains the chair's decision, since a majority is needed to overturn the chair.
Key Takeaway
In most cases, a tie = failure. The burden is always on a motion to pass, not to fail.