How can the general membership overturn a board decision
Asked November 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
How can the general membership overturn a board decision?
Overturning a Board Decision: Options for General Membership
There are several parliamentary tools available to the general membership, depending on the circumstances.
1. Rescind or Amend Something Previously Adopted (RONR §35)
If the board has taken action that the general membership wishes to reverse, the membership can move to Rescind (repeal entirely) or Amend Something Previously Adopted (modify it).
Vote Required:
- With previous notice: Simple majority vote
- Without previous notice: Two-thirds vote, OR a majority of the entire membership
Process:
- A member rises and addresses the chair
- The member makes the motion: "I move to rescind the board's action on [matter]..."
- The motion is seconded
- The motion is debated
- A vote is taken with the appropriate threshold
2. Appeal from the Board's Decision (if applicable)
This applies mainly to rulings made during a meeting, not general policy decisions.
3. Instruct the Board (RONR §49)
The membership can adopt a main motion directing the board to take or refrain from taking specific action — provided the board's authority isn't exclusive under the bylaws.
4. Amend the Bylaws (RONR §57)
If the board's authority itself is the issue, the membership can amend the bylaws to restrict board powers.
⚠️ Critical Caveats
Check your bylaws first. If the bylaws grant the board exclusive authority over certain matters, the membership may not be able to overturn those decisions without a bylaw amendment.
Completed vs. reversible actions: If the board's decision has already been fully carried out (e.g., money spent, a contract signed), rescinding may not be practically possible, though the motion can still be made for the record.
Timing matters: Action is easier to reverse before it is implemented.
Summary Table
| Method | When to Use | Vote Required |
|---|---|---|
| Rescind (with notice) | Reverse a board action | Majority |
| Rescind (without notice) | Reverse a board action | 2/3 or majority of all members |
| Instruct the Board | Direct future board action | Majority |
| Amend Bylaws | Change board's authority | Per bylaws (usually 2/3) |