How are resolutions from a committee report handled
Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
How are resolutions from a committee report handled under Robert's Rules?
Handling Resolutions from Committee Reports
Overview
When a committee submits a report containing one or more resolutions, specific procedures govern how those resolutions come before the assembly. The key principle is that resolutions in a committee report do not need to be moved from the floor — they are brought before the assembly through the reporting process itself.
Step-by-Step Procedure
1. Presenting the Report
- The committee chair (or designated member) presents the report to the assembly
- The reporting member reads or summarizes the report and any resolutions
2. Moving the Resolutions
The reporting member formally moves adoption using language such as:
"On behalf of the committee, I move the adoption of the following resolution: [reads resolution]"
- No second is required from another member — committee reports require no second since multiple members already agreed to the recommendation
- If the committee report contains multiple resolutions, they may be moved together or separately
3. Chair States the Question
The chair formally places the motion before the assembly:
"It is moved that the following resolution be adopted: [states resolution]"
4. Debate and Amendment
- The resolution is fully debatable and amendable by the assembly
- The assembly is not bound by the committee's recommendation
- Members may amend, refer back, postpone, or take any other appropriate action
5. Vote
- Adoption requires a majority vote unless the resolution deals with a matter requiring a higher threshold (e.g., a bylaws amendment)
Important Points
| Situation | Rule |
|---|---|
| Multiple resolutions in one report | May be considered together unless a member objects |
| Committee recommends against adoption | Assembly can still adopt; committee merely advises |
| Minority report submitted | Minority must move its resolution as a substitute for the majority's resolution |
| Report accepted vs. resolution adopted | These are different actions — accepting a report acknowledges receipt; adopting a resolution makes it policy |
"Accepted" vs. "Adopted" — A Critical Distinction
Accepting or receiving a report ≠ adopting its resolutions
- A motion to "accept the report" only acknowledges the report's receipt
- The assembly must separately vote to adopt each resolution to make it binding
Minority Reports
If a minority report is submitted:
- It is presented after the majority report
- The minority member moves their resolution as a substitute amendment to the majority's resolution
- The assembly then chooses between the two versions