Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


Does scope of notice apply to a general revision of the bylaws

Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


Does scope of notice apply to a general revision of the bylaws?

Scope of Notice and General Bylaw Revisions

The short answer: No — scope of notice does not apply to a general revision of the bylaws.

The General Rule on Scope of Notice

Normally, when previous notice is given for an amendment to the bylaws, the scope of notice limits how far the assembly can go in amending the proposed change. The assembly cannot adopt something that is more radical (further from the existing bylaws) or less radical (further from the proposed amendment) than either the existing provision or the noticed amendment.


The Exception: General Revision

A general revision is treated differently. Because a general revision essentially proposes an entirely new document as a substitute for the existing bylaws, the concept of "scope of notice" does not constrain the assembly's ability to amend it.

When a general revision is proposed, the assembly is free to amend any article or provision in any direction — it is not limited by what was in the original bylaws or by what the revision committee proposed.


Why the Distinction?

The rationale is logical:

  • Scope of notice exists to protect members by ensuring that amendments don't stray beyond what was reasonably anticipated from the notice given.
  • With a general revision, members are put on notice that the entire document is open for change, so no specific provision is shielded from amendment in any direction.

Practical Implications

When a general revision is before the assembly:

  • Any provision may be amended freely during consideration
  • Amendments may make provisions more or less restrictive than either the current bylaws or the draft revision
  • The assembly essentially has a clean slate within the scope of what a bylaws document can properly contain

Important Caveat

Even without scope-of-notice restrictions, any amendments during a general revision must still be germane to the article or section being considered, and the content must be appropriate for bylaws. Individual provisions may still require a 2/3 vote or previous notice to adopt depending on your organization's own rules.

Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions