Does Robert's Rules govern public comment at city council meetings
Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Does anything in Robert's Rules prohibit questions from the public during a city council meeting?
Public Comment and Robert's Rules
The short answer: Robert's Rules itself does not govern this — it's largely a matter of law and local rules.
What Robert's Rules Says
Robert's Rules is written for deliberative assemblies of members. City council meetings involve a complicating factor: the general public are not members of the assembly. Under Robert's Rules, non-members have no inherent right to speak, make motions, or participate in debate.
However, Robert's Rules explicitly acknowledges its own limitations here:
"The rules in this book are intended for use by deliberative assemblies...Legislative bodies are also subject to applicable law."
What Actually Controls Public Comment at City Councils
Public comment periods are typically governed by:
- State/local open meetings laws (often called "Sunshine Laws") — many states legally require public comment opportunities
- The council's own bylaws or standing rules
- Local ordinances governing meeting procedure
- Constitutional considerations (First Amendment in public forums)
Practical Implications
| Source | Effect |
|---|---|
| Robert's Rules alone | Would NOT require public comment |
| State open meetings law | Often mandates it |
| Local rules | Define format, time limits, sign-up procedures |
Bottom Line
If you're dealing with a situation where public comment is being restricted or denied, the relevant challenge would be based on your state's open meetings statute, not Robert's Rules. Robert's Rules simply isn't the controlling authority for this question.