Does an elections committee have to follow a nominations policy
Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Does an elections committee have to follow a nominations policy?
Elections Committee and Nominations Policy
Direct Answer
It depends on the source and wording of the policy. The short answer is: if the policy was properly adopted by the organization, the elections committee is generally bound by it — but the specifics matter greatly.
Key Considerations
1. Where Did the Policy Come From?
| Source | Binding Effect |
|---|---|
| Bylaws | Absolutely binding — supersedes everything |
| Special Rules of Order | Binding on all members and committees |
| Standing Rules / Policies | Generally binding, but may have flexibility |
| Motion of the assembly | Binding unless rescinded |
| Committee's own rules | Only binding on itself |
2. Committees Are Subordinate to the Assembly
Under **Robert's Rules, a committee derives its authority from the body that created it. It cannot act contrary to the will of the parent assembly or violate governing documents.
3. Scope of the Policy Matters
- Does the policy specifically apply to the elections committee?
- Does it govern nominations, elections, or both?
- Does it leave any discretion to the committee?
Practical Guidance
- If the nominations policy was adopted in the bylaws or standing rules, the elections committee must follow it
- If the committee violates a valid policy, the assembly can overrule, correct, or discharge the committee
- The committee may request the assembly amend or suspend a policy if it creates problems (note: bylaws typically cannot be suspended)
When in Doubt
Review your bylaws, standing rules, and any resolutions to determine the policy's authority level and whether it explicitly applies to the elections committee.