Does an ad hoc committee dissolve when its proposed amendments are tabled
Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
An ad hoc committee was elected by a congregation to draft and submit amendments to the organization's constitution. The committee did so, but at a meeting the amendments were tabled. Does the ad hoc committee cease to exist?
Ad Hoc Committee Status After Motion is Tabled
This is an excellent question that touches on both committee law and the effect of the motion to Lay on the Table.
Short Answer
No, tabling the amendments does not automatically dissolve the ad hoc committee — but the answer depends on how the committee's charge was defined.
Key Principles
1. The Motion to Lay on the Table Laying a motion on the table sets the motion aside temporarily — it does not kill it or finalize any action. The assembly retains the right to Take from the Table at any future session (within the same session or the next session). This means the business is technically unfinished, which bears on the committee's status.
2. Ad Hoc (Special) Committee Duration Under Robert's Rules, a special (ad hoc) committee exists to fulfill a specific charge and ceases to exist when:
- It submits its final report and the assembly discharges it, or
- It completes the specific task assigned to it, or
- The assembly formally dissolves it
Applying This to Your Situation
The critical question is: What exactly was the committee's charge?
| If the charge was... | Then... |
|---|---|
| "Draft and submit amendments" | The committee arguably completed its charge upon submission, and may be considered dissolved |
| "Draft, submit, and shepherd amendments through adoption" | The committee likely still exists, since adoption hasn't occurred |
| Broadly worded or unclear | The safer interpretation is that the committee continues to exist until formally discharged |
Since the amendments were tabled rather than adopted or rejected, the assembly's business is incomplete. A reasonable interpretation is that the committee remains in existence until either:
- The amendments are taken from the table and acted upon finally, or
- The assembly formally discharges the committee
Practical Recommendation
To avoid ambiguity, the assembly should formally discharge the committee if they no longer wish it to exist, using a motion:
"I move that the ad hoc constitutional amendments committee be discharged."
This requires a majority vote. Alternatively, if the intent is for the committee to remain available, no action is needed.
Bottom Line
Tabling the amendments suspended the business, not the committee. Until the assembly takes final action on the amendments or formally dissolves the committee, the committee likely still exists — particularly if its charge could be interpreted as broader than mere submission.