Does a motion pass when most members abstain but yes votes outnumber no votes
Asked November 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
If a voting body has 20 members and five vote for, four vote against, and the rest abstain, is that a majority vote? Does the motion pass?
Majority Vote Analysis
Yes, the motion passes.
How Majority Vote is Calculated Under Robert's Rules
A majority vote means more than half of the votes cast — and critically, abstentions are NOT counted as votes cast.
Breaking Down Your Example
| Category | Count |
|---|---|
| Total members present | 20 |
| Votes FOR | 5 |
| Votes AGAINST | 4 |
| Abstentions | 11 |
| Total votes cast | 9 |
- Majority required = more than half of 9 = more than 4.5 = at least 5
- Votes in favor = 5 ✓
The motion passes 5–4.
The Key Principle
Under Robert's Rules, a majority vote means more than half of the votes cast by persons entitled to vote, not counting blanks or abstentions.
Important Caveats
- Bylaws or special rules may define "majority" differently (e.g., "majority of members present" or "majority of the entire membership"), which would count abstentions against the motion
- If your rules require a majority of the entire membership, the motion would fail (5 is not a majority of 20)
- Always check your organization's governing documents for any special voting thresholds