Does a budget modification motion require a second if made by an officer or committee
Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
If a budget modification comes from an officer versus a committee, does it require a second?
Seconds for Budget Modification Motions
The Short Answer
Yes, a second is required regardless of whether the motion comes from an officer or a committee member — with one important exception.
The Key Distinction
Motion Made by an Individual (Officer or Otherwise)
If an officer or any individual member makes a motion to modify the budget, it requires a second before it can be considered.
The purpose of a second is simply to show that at least one other member wants the matter considered.
Motion Reported FROM a Committee
If the budget modification comes as a formal committee report/recommendation, it does NOT require a second.
Under Robert's Rules, a motion made on behalf of a committee of more than one member needs no second, because the committee's recommendation already shows that more than one member wants it considered.
Practical Examples
| Scenario | Second Required? |
|---|---|
| Treasurer moves to amend the budget | ✅ Yes |
| President moves to amend the budget | ✅ Yes |
| Budget Committee reports a recommended modification | ❌ No |
| Any individual member moves to amend | ✅ Yes |
Key Takeaway
The determining factor is not who makes the motion, but rather whether it originates from an individual or a formal committee recommendation.