Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


Does a budget modification motion require a second if made by an officer or committee

Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


If a budget modification comes from an officer versus a committee, does it require a second?

Seconds for Budget Modification Motions

The Short Answer

Yes, a second is required regardless of whether the motion comes from an officer or a committee member — with one important exception.


The Key Distinction

Motion Made by an Individual (Officer or Otherwise)

If an officer or any individual member makes a motion to modify the budget, it requires a second before it can be considered.

The purpose of a second is simply to show that at least one other member wants the matter considered.

Motion Reported FROM a Committee

If the budget modification comes as a formal committee report/recommendation, it does NOT require a second.

Under Robert's Rules, a motion made on behalf of a committee of more than one member needs no second, because the committee's recommendation already shows that more than one member wants it considered.


Practical Examples

Scenario Second Required?
Treasurer moves to amend the budget ✅ Yes
President moves to amend the budget ✅ Yes
Budget Committee reports a recommended modification ❌ No
Any individual member moves to amend ✅ Yes

Key Takeaway

The determining factor is not who makes the motion, but rather whether it originates from an individual or a formal committee recommendation.

Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions