Do meeting minutes record what was done or what was said
Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Do the minutes reflect what was done in a meeting or what was said?
Minutes Record What Was Done, Not What Was Said
This is a fundamental principle of parliamentary procedure under Robert's Rules.
The Basic Rule
Minutes should contain a record of all actions taken by the assembly, not a transcript or summary of the debate and discussion that occurred.
**Robert's Rules is clear on this point.
What Minutes SHOULD Include
- ✅ The type of meeting (regular, special, adjourned)
- ✅ Name of the organization and date/time/place
- ✅ Whether a quorum was present
- ✅ All motions made (with the exact wording)
- ✅ The name of the maker of each motion
- ✅ The outcome of each vote (adopted, defeated, etc.)
- ✅ Vote counts when ordered or when a counted vote was taken
- ✅ Points of order and appeals, and how they were ruled
- ✅ Time of adjournment
What Minutes SHOULD NOT Include
- ❌ Debate or discussion on motions
- ❌ Members' opinions or arguments
- ❌ Seconding member's name (unless required by bylaws)
- ❌ Personal commentary by the secretary
Key Principle
Under Robert's Rules, the minutes are mainly a record of what was done at the meeting, not of what was said by the members.
Important Note
If a member wants their position on record, they may request that their vote be recorded in the minutes, but their actual words are generally not included.