Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


Do committee recommendations require a second under Robert's Rules

Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


Do committee recommendations require a second when brought before the assembly?

Committee Recommendations and Seconds

No, a motion arising from a committee report does not require a second.

When a committee makes a recommendation to the assembly, the motion is considered to come before the assembly automatically — no second is needed.

Why No Second Is Required

The purpose of a second is to show that at least two members want to consider a matter. Since a committee (by definition, more than one person) has already deliberated and made a recommendation, that threshold is already satisfied — the committee's action itself demonstrates sufficient interest.

Robert's Rules — A second is not required when a motion is reported from a committee.


How It Works in Practice
  1. The committee chair (or reporting member) presents the report and states the recommendation
  2. The presiding officer states the question on the recommendation
  3. Debate and amendment proceed normally
  4. The assembly votes

Example: "The committee recommends the adoption of the following resolution: [text]. The motion is before you — is there any discussion?"


Important Caveat — Single-Member "Committees"

If someone was appointed as a committee of one, a second would be required, since no group deliberation occurred.


Bottom Line

For any properly constituted multi-member committee, skip the second and proceed directly to debate on the recommendation.

Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions