Do committee recommendations require a second under Robert's Rules
Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Do committee recommendations require a second when brought before the assembly?
Committee Recommendations and Seconds
No, a motion arising from a committee report does not require a second.
When a committee makes a recommendation to the assembly, the motion is considered to come before the assembly automatically — no second is needed.
Why No Second Is Required
The purpose of a second is to show that at least two members want to consider a matter. Since a committee (by definition, more than one person) has already deliberated and made a recommendation, that threshold is already satisfied — the committee's action itself demonstrates sufficient interest.
Robert's Rules — A second is not required when a motion is reported from a committee.
How It Works in Practice
- The committee chair (or reporting member) presents the report and states the recommendation
- The presiding officer states the question on the recommendation
- Debate and amendment proceed normally
- The assembly votes
Example: "The committee recommends the adoption of the following resolution: [text]. The motion is before you — is there any discussion?"
Important Caveat — Single-Member "Committees"
If someone was appointed as a committee of one, a second would be required, since no group deliberation occurred.
Bottom Line
For any properly constituted multi-member committee, skip the second and proceed directly to debate on the recommendation.