Do bylaws requiring simple majority apply to motions to limit debate
Asked November 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Our bylaws state that all issues require just a simple majority. Would this include a motion to limit debate?
Bylaws Overriding Robert's Rules' Default Requirements
This is an important question about the relationship between your bylaws and Robert's Rules' default rules.
The Short Answer
Yes, your bylaws provision would apply, reducing the vote threshold for limiting debate from the standard two-thirds to a simple majority.
How This Works
Under Robert's Rules, a motion to Limit or Extend Limits of Debate normally requires a two-thirds vote because it suppresses the fundamental right of members to debate. However:
Robert's Rules explicitly recognizes that an organization's bylaws can modify voting thresholds, and when they do, the bylaws take precedence over Robert's Rules' default rules.
If your bylaws state that all questions require a simple majority, that language is broad enough to encompass motions to limit debate.
Important Caveats
- Review the exact bylaw language carefully. Words like "all business" or "all questions" would clearly cover this. More restrictive wording might not.
- Some procedural rights are strongly protected. If members believe the bylaw was intended only for substantive motions, there could be a reasonable argument — but the plain language would generally control.
- Consider the implications — a simple majority could more easily shut down debate, which may or may not reflect your organization's intent.
Practical Recommendation
If there is any ambiguity, the assembly could adopt a special rule of order to clarify the intent, which would require a two-thirds vote to adopt.