Do bylaws or standing rules take precedence when they conflict
Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Do standing rules or bylaws win when there is a conflict between them?
Bylaws Prevail Over Standing Rules
Bylaws win. When there is a conflict between bylaws and standing rules, the bylaws take precedence.
The Hierarchy of Governing Documents
Robert's Rules establishes a clear hierarchy of authority:
| Priority | Document |
|---|---|
| 1 (Highest) | Federal/State/Local Law |
| 2 | Corporate Charter or Articles of Incorporation |
| 3 | Constitution (if separate from bylaws) |
| 4 | Bylaws |
| 5 | Parliamentary Authority (e.g., Robert's Rules) |
| 6 | Special Rules of Order |
| 7 | Standing Rules (Lowest) |
Why Bylaws Outrank Standing Rules
-
Bylaws are the organization's fundamental governing document, defining its structure, rights, and core procedures. They typically require a higher threshold to amend (often advance notice + a two-thirds vote, or a majority of the entire membership).
-
Standing rules are administrative policies adopted by a simple majority vote and can generally be suspended or amended more easily.
Because standing rules are easier to change, they cannot be used to override the more carefully protected provisions in the bylaws.
Practical Implication
If a standing rule conflicts with a bylaw provision, the standing rule is null and void to the extent of the conflict — it should be treated as if it doesn't exist until corrected.
Example: If the bylaws require a two-thirds vote to remove a member, a standing rule saying a majority vote suffices would be invalid.
Recommended Action
If you discover a conflict, the proper remedy is to amend the standing rule to bring it into conformity with the bylaws.