Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


Do all motions require a second under Robert's Rules

Asked August 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


Do all motions require a second?

Do All Motions Require a Second?

No — most motions require a second, but several important exceptions exist.


Purpose of a Second

A second indicates that at least one other member (besides the maker) wants the motion considered. It prevents the assembly from wasting time on a matter only one person wants to discuss. Notably, a second does not indicate agreement with the motion — only that it deserves consideration.


Motions That Do NOT Require a Second
Motion Reason
Point of Order Protects the assembly's rights — any member may raise it
Point of Information / Parliamentary Inquiry A question, not a proposal
Division of the Assembly Any member may demand a rising vote
Division of a Question Procedural right of members
Nominations Not a formal motion in the traditional sense
Requests and Inquiries generally These are questions, not proposals

Important Practical Note

In small boards (typically fewer than about 12 members) and committees, the requirement for a second is often dispensed with informally, as the purpose of a second — gauging interest — is already apparent in a small group.


The Standard Rule

For all main motions, subsidiary motions, privileged motions, and most incidental motions, a second is required before the chair states the question and opens debate.


Bottom line: The second requirement is the norm, but know your exceptions — particularly Points of Order and Division of the Assembly, which come up frequently in meetings.

Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions