Can you rescind a dues waiver vote after the recipients paid their dues
Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
A vote was taken at one meeting to grant free lifetime dues to two founding members of our social organization. Our bylaws state dues are due by October 1st each year. During the vote some discussion occurred, but the motion still passed. At the following meeting, one member attempted to rescind the vote but was erroneously told she needed to give prior notice to do so. I then submitted written notice of my intent to move to rescind the vote during old business at the next meeting. I received no reply from the secretary or president. In the meantime, both founding members paid their dues as required under the existing rules — the lifetime waiver was intended to be a surprise announced at an upcoming event. The benefit (free dues for the rest of their lives) has not yet been formally conferred. Can I still make the motion to rescind?
Motion to Rescind — Your Situation
Direct Answer: Yes, you can still make the motion to rescind.
Why You Can Still Bring This Motion
1. Your Notice Is Valid
You provided written notice of your intent to move to rescind prior to the meeting. This notice is effective regardless of whether the secretary or president acknowledged it. Robert's Rules does not require acknowledgment — notice was given.
2. Payment of Dues Does Not Necessarily Bar Rescission
This is a critical point. Robert's Rules states that a motion cannot be rescinded if something has been done as a result of the vote that it is impossible to undo. However:
- The founding members paying their own dues under existing rules is not an action taken as a result of the vote granting the waiver
- That vote was about granting them free lifetime dues going forward
- No irreversible benefit has yet been conferred — they simply paid as they were required to under current rules
- The future benefit (lifetime free dues) has not yet been received or relied upon in an irreversible way
Under Robert's Rules, Rescind is not in order when something has been done as a result of the vote that is impossible to undo, though the part of an order that has not yet been carried out can still be rescinded.
The Procedural Path Forward
During Old Business at the Next Meeting:
| Step | Action |
|---|---|
| 1 | Rise and seek recognition from the chair |
| 2 | State: "I move to rescind the motion adopted at our [prior] meeting granting lifetime free dues to the two founding members" |
| 3 | Motion requires a second |
| 4 | Motion is debatable |
| 5 | Vote required: Because you gave prior notice, only a simple majority is needed to pass. Without notice it would require a 2/3 vote |
Correcting the Earlier Meeting Error
The member at the earlier meeting was incorrectly told she needed to give notice first. Under Robert's Rules, notice is not required to make the motion to rescind — it simply changes the vote threshold:
- With previous notice → Majority vote required
- Without previous notice → 2/3 vote required (or majority of the entire membership)
She could have made the motion without notice; it simply would have needed a higher vote threshold to pass.
Important Caveats
⚠️ Check your bylaws. If your bylaws contain specific provisions about dues waivers, member benefits, or the process for rescinding such actions, those rules may govern over Robert's Rules.
⚠️ The "surprise" element is a practical concern, not a parliamentary one. Rescission is a legitimate parliamentary action regardless of the members' expectations.
⚠️ If the motion fails, the lifetime dues waiver stands and cannot easily be revisited without new circumstances arising.
Bottom Line
Your notice was properly given, the motion is in order, and you have every right to bring it forward. The payment of dues by the founding members under existing rules does not constitute an irreversible execution of the waiver vote that would prevent rescission under **Robert's Rules.