Can you hold a meeting when quorum is based on outdated membership records
Asked November 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Our quorum requirement may be based on outdated information. Can we still hold a meeting?
Quorum Based on Outdated Information
This is a great practical question. Let me break it down:
The Core Principle
Under Robert's Rules, quorum is determined by your governing documents (bylaws, constitution, etc.) — not by what the chair or members believe it to be. The actual quorum requirement is what controls, regardless of what anyone thinks it is.
Common Scenarios
1. Your Bylaws State a Fixed Number
"A quorum shall be 10 members"
The quorum is 10, full stop. If your membership has shrunk or grown, that fixed number still applies until the bylaws are amended.
2. Your Bylaws State a Percentage
"A quorum shall be a majority of the membership"
Then the quorum automatically adjusts as membership changes. If your membership rolls are outdated, you have a data problem — the organization needs accurate membership records to calculate quorum.
Practical Guidance
| Situation | What to Do |
|---|---|
| Fixed number in bylaws | Meet if that number is present |
| Percentage-based, outdated rolls | Update records before meeting if possible |
| Uncertainty about current quorum | Err on the side of caution; don't conduct business |
If You Proceed Without Proper Quorum
Any business transacted without quorum is null and void. This is a serious procedural defect that can invalidate all actions taken.
Recommended Solutions
- Amend your bylaws to update the fixed quorum number (requires proper notice and vote)
- Update your membership rolls if quorum is percentage-based
- Consult your bylaws carefully for any special provisions
⚠️ Important Caveat
Your organization's specific bylaws, special rules, and applicable law may override Robert's Rules defaults. If this involves a corporation or nonprofit, state law may also impose quorum requirements.