Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


Can you amend an amendment under Robert's Rules

Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


Can you amend an amendment?

Amending an Amendment

Yes! You can amend an amendment — this is called a secondary amendment.

The Two Levels of Amendment

Robert's Rules recognizes two levels of amendments:

Level Name What It Does
1st degree Primary amendment Amends the main motion directly
2nd degree Secondary amendment Amends the primary amendment

The Critical Limit

You cannot go further than two degrees. There is no such thing as a "third degree" amendment (an amendment to an amendment to an amendment). Robert's Rules is explicit on this point.

Practical Example

  1. Main motion: "That the club donate $500 to charity."
  2. Primary amendment: "Strike '$500' and insert '$300'"
  3. Secondary amendment: "Strike '$300' and insert '$400'"

All three are pending simultaneously, and the assembly votes in reverse order:

  • First vote: on the secondary amendment
  • Second vote: on the primary amendment (as possibly amended)
  • Third vote: on the main motion (as possibly amended)

Key Rules for Secondary Amendments

  • Requires a second
  • Is debatable
  • Requires a majority vote
  • Must be germane to the primary amendment it is amending

Important Note

Once a secondary amendment is pending, no further amendments are in order until it is resolved.

Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions