Can you amend an amendment under Robert's Rules
Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Can you amend an amendment?
Amending an Amendment
Yes! You can amend an amendment — this is called a secondary amendment.
The Two Levels of Amendment
Robert's Rules recognizes two levels of amendments:
| Level | Name | What It Does |
|---|---|---|
| 1st degree | Primary amendment | Amends the main motion directly |
| 2nd degree | Secondary amendment | Amends the primary amendment |
The Critical Limit
You cannot go further than two degrees. There is no such thing as a "third degree" amendment (an amendment to an amendment to an amendment). Robert's Rules is explicit on this point.
Practical Example
- Main motion: "That the club donate $500 to charity."
- Primary amendment: "Strike '$500' and insert '$300'"
- Secondary amendment: "Strike '$300' and insert '$400'"
All three are pending simultaneously, and the assembly votes in reverse order:
- First vote: on the secondary amendment
- Second vote: on the primary amendment (as possibly amended)
- Third vote: on the main motion (as possibly amended)
Key Rules for Secondary Amendments
- Requires a second
- Is debatable
- Requires a majority vote
- Must be germane to the primary amendment it is amending
Important Note
Once a secondary amendment is pending, no further amendments are in order until it is resolved.