Can two members pass a motion when the third abstains at minimum quorum
Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
We have 3 members present, which meets our quorum requirement, but one member has to abstain on a motion. Can the remaining 2 members approve it?
Voting with Minimum Quorum and an Abstention
Short Answer: Yes, in most cases.
Under Robert's Rules, abstentions are not counted as votes cast. They are simply a member choosing not to vote. This means only the actual "Yes" and "No" votes are counted when determining whether a motion passes.
How the Math Works
With 3 members present (quorum met) and 1 abstaining:
| Vote | Count |
|---|---|
| Yes | 2 |
| No | 0 |
| Abstain | — (not counted) |
| Votes Cast | 2 |
A majority vote requires more than half of the votes actually cast — not half of members present.
✅ 2 Yes votes out of 2 votes cast = 100% majority → Motion PASSES
Key Robert's Rules Principles
- A majority vote means "more than half of the votes cast by members present and voting"
- Members who abstain are "present but not voting" and are excluded from the calculation
- Quorum (the number needed in the room) is separate from the vote threshold
Important Caveats
- Check your bylaws — some organizations require a majority of the entire membership or members present, which would change the math
- If the motion requires a two-thirds vote, 2 out of 2 still satisfies that threshold
- Quorum must be maintained throughout the meeting — confirm all 3 remain present
Bottom line: Two "Yes" votes from a body of 3 (with one abstention) is perfectly valid under standard Robert's Rules rules.