Can the subject of a grievance resolution move to rescind or amend it
Asked August 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Under Robert's Rules, can an officer who was the subject of a board's prior grievance resolution personally move to amend or rescind that resolution, or must the motion be made by another board member?
Rescinding or Amending a Prior Resolution: Who May Make the Motion
Direct Answer
Under Robert's Rules, any member of the board may move to Amend Something Previously Adopted or to Rescind — including the officer who was the subject of the prior grievance resolution. Robert's Rules imposes no restriction on who among the members may make the motion based on their personal interest in the matter.
Relevant Robert's Rules Authority
**Robert's Rules governs motions to Rescind and to Amend Something Previously Adopted. The section specifies:
- The motion may be made by any member — it carries no eligibility restriction based on the maker's relationship to the subject matter.
- It requires a second, is debatable, and is amendable.
- It requires either:
- A two-thirds (2/3) vote, or
- A majority vote with previous notice, or
- A majority of the entire membership
The Separate Question of Voting
While the officer may make the motion, a distinct issue arises regarding whether they may vote on it:
Robert's Rules states that a member has an obligation to vote except when they have a direct personal interest not common to other members, in which case they should abstain — but under Robert's Rules, they are not prohibited from voting.
However:
- Bylaws or organizational rules may impose stricter conflict-of-interest standards.
- State nonprofit or corporate law may require abstention in certain fiduciary contexts.
⚠️ Always check your bylaws and applicable law, as they may override Robert's Rules' permissive default.
Practical Considerations
| Issue | Robert's Rules Default Rule |
|---|---|
| May the officer make the motion? | ✅ Yes — no restriction |
| Must someone else second it? | ✅ Yes — a second is required |
| May the officer debate the motion? | ✅ Yes |
| May the officer vote on it? | ✅ Yes (but should consider abstaining) |
| Can the chair rule them out of order for making it? | ❌ No — improper under Robert's Rules |
Summary
Robert's Rules places no restriction on who initiates a motion to rescind or amend a prior action. The officer in question has full standing to make the motion. The more sensitive procedural and ethical question involves their participation in debate and voting, which Robert's Rules leaves to their discretion but which local rules or law may further restrict.