Can the secretary stop sending draft minutes to the presiding officer before distribution
Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Our secretary has stopped a longtime custom of sending the draft minutes to the presiding officer before distributing them to the full assembly. Is the secretary required to share minutes with the chair in advance, and what can be done about it?
Secretary Withholding Minutes from Presiding Officer
This is a legitimate procedural concern. Here's the full picture:
The Secretary's Duty
Under Robert's Rules, the secretary's obligations regarding minutes are clear:
- The secretary is required to have the minutes available for the presiding officer's review
- Minutes are the official record of the assembly, and the presiding officer has a legitimate interest in reviewing them for accuracy before distribution
- This practice also helps the chair prepare to lead the approval process at the next meeting
Is Pre-Distribution Review Required by Robert's Rules?
Strictly speaking, Robert's Rules does not explicitly mandate that minutes be sent to the presiding officer before the assembly. However:
- If your bylaws, standing rules, or established custom require this, the secretary is obligated to follow it
- A longstanding custom can carry the force of a standing rule if consistently followed
Remedies Available
| Option | How |
|---|---|
| Point of Order | Raise at the next meeting if the secretary's conduct violates a rule |
| Standing Rule | Move to adopt a formal rule requiring pre-meeting distribution to the chair |
| Motion to Censure | If the conduct is a pattern of neglect of duty |
| Removal from Office | As a last resort per Robert's Rules |
Recommended Action
The cleanest fix is to formalize what was previously customary by adopting a standing rule specifying that minutes be provided to the presiding officer (and/or all members) within a set number of days before the meeting.