Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


Can the secretary stop sending draft minutes to the presiding officer before distribution

Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


Our secretary has stopped a longstanding custom of sending the minutes to the presiding officer before distributing them to the assembly. Is this a procedural problem, and what can be done about it?

Secretary Withholding Minutes from Presiding Officer

This is a genuine procedural and governance concern. Here's a breakdown of the issue:

What Robert's Rules Requires

Under **Robert's Rules, the secretary has the duty to keep and distribute minutes, but the minutes belong to the organization, not to any individual officer. The secretary serves the assembly, not any single officer.

However, longstanding practice and sound procedure generally support the presiding officer reviewing minutes before distribution because:

  • The chair can catch errors in recorded rulings
  • The chair can flag procedural inaccuracies before they circulate
  • It is a widely recognized customary courtesy

The Core Problem

If this custom has been consistently followed, it may rise to the level of a standing rule or established practice of the organization. Unilaterally abandoning it could be a breach of duty.


Remedies Available to the Assembly

Action How
Point of Order Raised at next meeting challenging the secretary's conduct
Adopt a Standing Rule Formally codify the pre-distribution review requirement
Motion to Censure Formally reprimand the secretary (majority vote)
Remove from Office If misconduct is serious/repeated (per bylaws or **Robert's Rules)

Recommended Immediate Steps

  1. The presiding officer should formally request the minutes in writing before next distribution
  2. If refused, raise a Point of Order at the next meeting
  3. The assembly should adopt a standing rule formalizing the practice going forward

Important Caveat

If your bylaws or standing rules already address minutes distribution, those rules control. Check your governing documents first.

Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions