Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


Can the secretary make a motion and who records the minutes when they do

Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


If the secretary presents a motion but does not request a secretary pro tem, what should happen?

Secretary Presenting a Motion

This creates a conflict of interest that requires the secretary to temporarily step aside from their official duties while the motion is pending.


The Problem

The secretary has two incompatible roles when they present a motion:

  1. As a member — they are an interested party advocating for their motion
  2. As secretary — they are an impartial officer responsible for recording business accurately
What Should Happen

When the secretary makes a motion, the chair should automatically appoint a Secretary Pro Tem to handle the minutes during consideration of that motion, even if the secretary does not request one. This protects the integrity of the record.

*Robert's Rules addresses the secretary's duties and the need for impartiality in recording proceedings.


Practical Concerns If No Pro Tem Is Appointed
  • The secretary may be recording debate and votes on their own motion, creating a conflict
  • Minutes could be perceived as biased or inaccurate
  • The secretary should at minimum recuse themselves from recording during that portion

Best Practice

The chair should proactively appoint a Secretary Pro Tem the moment the secretary rises to make a motion — the secretary need not request it.

The appointed Pro Tem serves only for that specific item of business, after which the regular secretary resumes duties.

Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions