Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


Can the president or chair make a motion and ask for a second

Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


Can a president move an idea and then ask for a first and second motion?

President Making Motions

Short Answer: The president (chair) can make a motion, but it is strongly discouraged under Robert's Rules and creates procedural problems.


The Problem with the Chair Making Motions

Under Robert's Rules, the presiding officer is expected to remain impartial and facilitate debate — not participate in it. Specifically:

  • The chair should not make motions from the chair
  • The chair should not debate while presiding
  • Doing so compromises the chair's neutrality and appearance of fairness

A Note on Correct Terminology

Also worth clarifying: the proper process is:

  1. A member makes (or "moves") a motion
  2. Another member seconds it
  3. The chair then states the question to the assembly

There is no such thing as asking for a "first and second motion" — there is only asking if there is a second to the motion already made.


If the President Wants to Participate

If the president genuinely wants to make motions or debate, the proper procedure is to:

  1. Temporarily vacate the chair — hand the gavel to the vice president or another officer
  2. Step down to the floor as a regular member
  3. Make the motion and participate in debate
  4. Not resume the chair until that matter is fully resolved

Bottom Line

While a president technically has the right as a member, actively making motions while presiding undermines impartiality. Best practice is to step aside and let another member introduce the idea, or formally relinquish the chair temporarily.

Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions