Can the maker of a motion speak against their own motion
Asked November 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Can the person who makes a motion speak against it during debate?
Speaking Against Your Own Motion
No — under Robert's Rules, the maker of a motion may not speak against their own motion, though they may vote against it.
The Rule
The member who makes a motion is presumed to favor it. While they:
- ✅ May speak in favor of the motion (and have the right to be recognized first in debate)
- ✅ May vote against the motion
- ❌ May NOT speak against the motion during debate
Under Robert's Rules, the maker of a motion may vote against it but may not speak against it in debate.
Practical Guidance
If the maker of a motion has changed their mind about it, the proper options are:
- Withdraw the motion — before debate begins, the maker may request to withdraw it. After debate has begun, withdrawal requires majority approval of the assembly.
- Move to postpone indefinitely — this would effectively kill the motion and allow full debate.
- Simply vote against it — say nothing in debate and vote no.
Why This Rule Exists
This rule reflects the principle that a member vouches for the legitimacy of a motion by making it, even if they later have doubts. The assembly's time is best protected by this standard.