Can the chair vote like any other member when bylaws are silent on the issue
Asked November 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Our bylaws and constitution require a majority to pass a motion, but they do not state that the chair may only vote to break a tie. Does the chair vote like everyone else?
Can the Chair Vote When the Bylaws Are Silent?
Short answer
Yes, the chair keeps the right to vote, but in most assemblies the chair should use it only in particular situations. If the presiding officer is a member, the bylaws don't need to say anything for the chair to have a vote. What Robert's Rules adds is a rule about when the chair should cast it, so the chair stays impartial.
In a regular meeting or assembly
The chair should vote only:
- When the vote is by ballot. The chair votes along with everyone else, since a secret ballot doesn't compromise impartiality.
- When the chair's vote would change the result. The chair can vote to break a tie (making the motion pass) or to create a tie (making it fail, since a tie defeats a motion that needs a majority). On a two-thirds vote, the chair can likewise vote to reach or block the two-thirds.
On an ordinary voice vote or show of hands where the chair's vote wouldn't matter, the chair does not vote. This is part of Robert's Rules itself, not just a custom, though the bylaws or special rules can change it.
In a small board or committee
In a small board (about a dozen members or fewer) and in committees, the procedure is more informal and the chair may vote on every question like any other member.
Applying this to your situation
| Situation | Chair votes? |
|---|---|
| Ballot vote | Yes |
| Voice vote or show of hands, chair's vote would change the outcome | Yes, if the chair chooses |
| Voice vote or show of hands, chair's vote would not matter (large assembly) | No |
| Small board or committee | Yes, on any question |
| Bylaws say the chair votes only to break ties | Follow the bylaws |
If your organization wants a different practice, adopt it in the bylaws or as a special rule of order.