Can the chair remove a member from a meeting for being out of order
Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Under the current version of Robert's Rules, can the chair excuse or remove a member from a meeting simply for being called out of order?
Removing a Member from a Meeting Under Robert's Rules
No — the chair alone does not have the authority to excuse or remove a member from a meeting simply for being called out of order. This is an important limitation on the chair's authority.
What the Chair Can Do
The chair may:
- Call a member to order for improper conduct or language
- Warn the member about their behavior
- Require the member to be seated and stop speaking
What Removes a Member — The Proper Process
Removing a disorderly member requires action by the assembly itself, not unilateral action by the chair. The process under **Robert's Rules is:
- The chair calls the member to order
- If the behavior continues, the assembly (not the chair) may vote to:
- Censure the member, or
- Require the member to leave the meeting for the remainder of the session
- This requires a majority vote of the assembly
In Cases of Extreme Disorder
If a member's conduct is so disruptive that it constitutes a breach of decorum threatening the meeting, the chair may:
- Briefly recess the meeting to restore order
- In extreme cases, work with a sergeant-at-arms (if one exists) under the assembly's authority
Key Principle
The chair is a servant of the assembly, not its authority. Disciplinary action that affects a member's right to participate belongs to the membership, not to the presiding officer alone.