Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


Can the chair instruct a committee chair to make a motion to amend

Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


The chair said: "In October, the membership voted to increase the proposed 2027 Program Budget to $20,000 and the CASA budget to $500. The full 2027 budget has not yet been adopted. The question before us is the motion to adopt the proposed 2027 budget, as amended in October. The Budget Committee has a recommendation to amend it. [Name], Chair of the Budget Committee, you are recognized to make the motion to amend." Is this correctly stated?

Analysis of the Chair's Statement

The chair's statement is mostly correct in substance, but contains a significant procedural error in the final instruction.


✅ What Is Correct
  • Summarizing the current status of the pending business (the amended budget motion) before proceeding is good practice
  • Noting that the main motion is "as amended in October" correctly identifies the current form of the question
  • Recognizing the Budget Committee chair to present the committee's recommendation is appropriate

❌ The Problem: "Make the motion to amend"

The chair instructs the Budget Committee chair to "make the motion to amend," but this is not how committee recommendations work under Robert's Rules.

When a committee reports a recommendation to amend a pending motion:

  • The committee chair reports the recommendation — she does not move it herself
  • After the report, any member may move to adopt the committee's recommendation
  • Alternatively, the assembly chair may ask, "Will someone move to adopt the committee's recommendation?"

*Robert's Rules — A committee member reporting a recommendation is presenting it on behalf of the committee, not making a personal motion.


✅ Suggested Corrected Closing

*"[The Budget Committee chair], you are recognized to report the committee's recommendation."

After the report, the chair would then say:

"The committee recommends [amendment]. Is there a motion to adopt the committee's recommendation?"


Summary
Element Assessment
Status summary of prior amendment ✅ Correct
Identifying the pending main motion ✅ Correct
Recognizing committee chair ✅ Correct
Directing her to "make the motion" ❌ Should be "report the recommendation"
Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions