Can the chair ask if anyone wants to limit debate time before discussion begins
Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
A motion has been made and seconded, and discussion is about to begin. Can the chair ask if anyone wants to limit or extend the time each person has to speak?
Chair Initiating a Limit or Extend Debate Motion
Direct Answer
No — the chair should not make or suggest this motion. The chair must remain impartial and cannot make motions from the chair. However, the chair can facilitate the process in a neutral way.
What the Chair Can and Cannot Do
| Action | Permissible? |
|---|---|
| Make the motion to Limit/Extend Debate | ❌ No |
| Suggest or advocate for limiting debate | ❌ No |
| Recognize a member who wishes to make such a motion | ✅ Yes |
| Ask neutrally if any member wishes to make a motion before debate begins | ✅ Arguably yes, with caution |
The Proper Approach
If the chair is concerned about time, the correct procedure is to simply open the floor to debate and allow a member to rise and move:
"I move to limit debate to two minutes per speaker."
That motion then requires:
- A second
- No debate (it is not debatable)
- A two-thirds vote to adopt
Important Caveat
If the chair routinely suggests procedural motions, even neutrally, this can create an appearance of bias or coaching. Best practice is to let members manage the business and have the chair simply open debate:
"The motion is open for debate. Is there any discussion?"
**Robert's Rules — The chair is obligated to remain impartial and may not make motions while presiding. A chair wishing to make a motion must vacate the chair temporarily.