Can the board waive late dues fees caused by a technical failure beyond members' control
Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
The bylaws establish a late fee for member dues not received after September 30th. Members are unable to pay their dues because of a computer problem with the national headquarters, so most members' dues will be late through no fault of their own. In this situation, can the Board of Directors waive the late fees?
Waiving Late Fees Due to Circumstances Beyond Members' Control
This is an excellent practical question that involves the intersection of bylaw interpretation and board authority.
The Short Answer
It depends on what authority the bylaws grant to the Board of Directors. There is no single Robert's Rules rule that automatically permits or prohibits this — the answer lies in your organization's own governing documents.
Key Considerations
1. Check the Bylaws for Board Authority The board may waive the fees if the bylaws:
- Grant the board general management authority over the organization's affairs, OR
- Specifically grant the board authority over dues administration or financial matters
2. If the Bylaws Are Silent on Board Authority Under Robert's Rules, a board may only act within the powers granted to it by the bylaws and the assembly. If the bylaws establish a mandatory late fee with no exception clause, the board alone may not have authority to waive it — that would require action by the membership.
3. The Equity Argument Robert's Rules recognizes that no penalty rule is intended to punish members for circumstances entirely outside their control. A technical failure at an outside organization is a strong equitable argument that the late fee provision was never intended to apply in this situation.
Recommended Courses of Action
| Scenario | Recommended Action |
|---|---|
| Board has broad management authority in bylaws | Board may vote to waive fees for this specific period |
| Board authority is limited or unclear | Bring to a general membership meeting for a vote |
| Bylaws have an explicit late fee with no exceptions | Membership should vote; consider amending bylaws to add an exception clause |
| Urgent situation before a meeting can be called | Board acts provisionally; membership ratifies at next meeting |
Best Practice Recommendation
The board should:
- Document the circumstances (the third-party technical failure) thoroughly in the minutes
- Pass a resolution waiving the late fees for this specific incident with a clear rationale
- Report this action to the membership at the next general meeting, and if the board's authority to do so is questionable, seek ratification by the membership
Under Robert's Rules, the membership can ratify an action the board took without proper authority, as long as the membership itself could have authorized that action in advance.
Bottom Line
Acting in good faith to protect members from a penalty caused by a third-party technical failure is both equitable and defensible. Even if board authority is uncertain, acting provisionally and seeking membership ratification is a sound parliamentary path forward.