Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


Can the board fill a nominating committee slate vacancy before an election

Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


A club board elected a Nominating Committee. A proposed slate was put together and presented to the membership. Prior to the vote, a candidate withdrew from the slate. The board then convened and placed their chosen candidate in that vacancy. Is this allowed prior to the election?

Nominating Committee Authority After Slate Presentation

This is an excellent procedural question, and the answer depends on who has the authority to fill vacancies in the slate — which hinges on your bylaws and the nature of the Nominating Committee.


The Core Issue

Under Robert's Rules, the board likely did NOT have the authority to fill that vacancy unilaterally.

Here is why:


How Robert's Rules Addresses This

The Nominating Committee "owns" the slate until it is presented to the membership for election. The committee's function is to present nominees to the membership — that authority belongs to the committee, not the board.

Key principles:

  1. The Nominating Committee is a committee of the membership, even if elected by the board. Its authority to nominate is independent of the board once constituted.

  2. The board generally has no authority to modify the slate produced by a Nominating Committee. Doing so would be an overreach of board authority, as the board typically cannot act for the assembly in matters reserved to the membership or its committees.

  3. The proper remedy when a nominee withdraws would be:

    • The Nominating Committee reconvenes to fill the vacancy in the slate, OR
    • The membership itself fills the vacancy through nominations from the floor at the election meeting

What Should Have Happened
Situation Proper Authority
Vacancy in slate before election Nominating Committee reconvenes
Nominating Committee unable to act Nominations from the floor at the election
Board filling the vacancy ❌ Not proper under Robert's Rules

Important Caveats

Your bylaws control. If your bylaws or standing rules specifically grant the board authority to fill nominating slate vacancies, then the board's action could be valid. Always check your governing documents first.


Recommended Action

If the bylaws are silent on this, a Point of Order or Appeal would be appropriate at the election meeting challenging the board-substituted candidate's placement on the official slate. The membership could also simply vote for any eligible candidate through nominations from the floor, which are always in order unless the bylaws explicitly prohibit them.

Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions