Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


Can main motions be made at the same meeting a 5-day advance notice rule is adopted

Asked November 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


A standing rule requiring 5-day advance notice for main motions is proposed and adopted during a meeting. A main motion not on the agenda is then requested after the standing rule is adopted. Is this allowed?

Advance Notice Standing Rule vs. Subsequent Main Motion

This is an excellent procedural question. The short answer is: it depends on how the standing rule is worded and what threshold was required to adopt it.


The Core Issue

When an assembly adopts a standing rule requiring 5-day advance notice for main motions, that rule becomes binding on the assembly going forward. A main motion introduced at the same meeting without prior notice would appear to conflict with the newly adopted rule.

However, there are important nuances:


Key Procedural Principles

1. The Assembly Controls Its Own Rules Under **Robert's Rules, the assembly retains the power to suspend or set aside its own rules, including standing rules, by a majority vote (standing rules, unlike special rules of order, do not require a 2/3 vote to suspend).

Standing rules may be suspended for the duration of a session by a majority vote.

2. Suspension of the Rule If a member wishes to introduce a main motion without 5-day advance notice, the proper procedure is:

  1. Move to suspend the standing rule requiring advance notice
  2. Requires a second
  3. Not debatable
  4. Requires a majority vote to suspend

3. Without Suspension If no motion to suspend is made, the chair should rule the motion out of order as it violates the standing rule just adopted.


Important Caveat

If the advance notice rule was adopted at the same session, it generally takes effect immediately upon adoption unless the motion specified otherwise. The assembly cannot then casually ignore it without formally suspending it.


Bottom Line
Scenario Result
Motion introduced without suspension Out of order
Assembly votes to suspend the rule first Allowed
Bylaws require advance notice (not just standing rule) Cannot be suspended

⚠️ Important: If the notice requirement is in the bylaws, it cannot be suspended at all — that is a key distinction from a standing rule.

Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions