Can main motions be made at the same meeting a 5-day advance notice rule is adopted
Asked November 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
A standing rule requiring 5-day advance notice for all main motions is adopted at a meeting. Are further main motions allowed after its adoption at that same meeting?
Standing Rule Requiring Advance Notice for Main Motions
Direct Answer
Yes, further main motions are generally allowed at the same meeting after the rule is adopted, but this depends on how the rule is worded and when it takes effect.
Key Procedural Analysis
Immediate vs. Future Effect
A standing rule, once adopted, takes effect immediately unless it specifies otherwise. However, there is an important practical distinction:
- Motions already pending at the time of adoption are not affected — they were introduced before the rule existed.
- New main motions introduced after adoption at that same meeting would arguably fall under the new rule immediately.
This creates a logical tension: if the rule requires 5-day advance notice, and it was just adopted moments ago, no new main motions could be in order for the remainder of that meeting unless they had already been noticed in advance.
The Practical Outcome
| Situation | Result |
|---|---|
| Motions already on the agenda | Likely still in order |
| New main motions introduced after adoption | Out of order under the new rule |
| Motions with prior 5-day notice given | In order |
Important Caveats
**Robert's Rules notes that standing rules govern routine administrative detail. The assembly has the right to suspend a standing rule by majority vote (unlike bylaws, which cannot be suspended). So members could move to suspend the rule for a particular motion if needed.
Suspension of a Standing Rule:
- Requires a majority vote (no second needed if the chair proposes it, but typically moved by a member)
- Is non-debatable
- Applies only to that specific instance
Recommendation
If the assembly intends to continue conducting business with main motions at the same meeting, it should either:
- Specify in the motion that the rule takes effect at the next meeting, or
- Be prepared to suspend the rule as needed for that session.
The assembly controls its own rules and may clarify the intent through the wording of the motion adopting the rule.