Can floor nominations be used with no vetting process when forming a new organization
Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Our group is forming a new section and will be ratifying our bylaws on the same day as the election. Since the bylaws aren't in place yet, anyone can be nominated from the floor with no vetting process and no candidate bios submitted in advance. Can this be done under Robert's Rules?
Floor Nominations Without Bylaws or Vetting
Short Answer
Yes, this can absolutely be done under Robert's Rules. Floor nominations are a standard, recognized procedure, and when bylaws haven't yet been adopted, the assembly has broad flexibility in how it conducts its first elections.
What Robert's Rules Says About Nominations
**Robert's Rules covers nominations and elections. Key points:
- Floor nominations are explicitly recognized as one of the standard methods for making nominations
- When no rules restrict nominations, any member in good standing may be nominated from the floor
- There is no Robert's Rules requirement for pre-screening, bios, or vetting processes
- Nominations do not require a second
Your Specific Situation — Organizing a New Section
When forming a new organization before bylaws are in place:
- The assembly operates on general parliamentary law (Robert's Rules as the baseline)
- A temporary chair presides over the organizational meeting
- The group has maximum flexibility to set its own procedures by majority vote
- Once bylaws are ratified, those rules govern going forward
Typical Organizational Meeting Flow:
- Call to order by organizer/temporary chair
- Elect a temporary chair and secretary
- Adopt bylaws
- Conduct elections under newly adopted bylaws (or under Robert's Rules if bylaws are silent)
Practical Considerations
While it is procedurally valid, the assembly may want to consider:
| Option | How to Accomplish |
|---|---|
| Request candidates briefly introduce themselves | Simple procedural rule adopted by majority vote |
| Allow written bios to be submitted in advance | Announce as a courtesy prior to the meeting |
| Set a brief speech time per nominee | Adopt as a special rule by 2/3 vote |
Key Takeaway
Robert's Rules places no vetting requirement on candidates. The assembly itself is the ultimate authority on who is qualified, expressed through the vote. If members want more structure, they can adopt temporary rules at the start of the meeting.