Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


Can discussion continue online after a motion is debated and voted on remotely

Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


A motion was made at a live meeting, discussion happened during that meeting, but the vote is being taken online afterward. Is further discussion allowed in the online space?

Online Voting After In-Person Discussion

This question touches on a scenario Robert's Rules addresses carefully.

The Short Answer

It depends on what your bylaws or rules authorize — but under standard Robert's Rules principles, there are significant concerns with this arrangement.


The Core Issue: "Online Voting" vs. "Online Meetings"

Robert's Rules draws an important distinction:

❌ Asynchronous Online Voting (email, online polls, etc.)

Under **Robert's Rules, an organization's business must be conducted in a deliberative assembly — a body that meets to discuss and act together. Robert's Rules does not authorize asynchronous online voting (where members vote at different times) unless the bylaws explicitly permit it.

Under Robert's Rules, unless the bylaws authorize otherwise, an organization or board can transact business only at a properly called meeting with a quorum present, where members can take part in debate together.

If your bylaws do authorize this method, they should also specify the rules governing it, including whether further discussion is permitted.

✅ Synchronous Online Meetings

If the "online vote" is actually conducted in a real-time online meeting (video conference, etc.), that is treated as a continuation or separate meeting, and normal debate rules would apply.


Practical Guidance

Scenario Further Discussion Allowed?
Bylaws authorize async online vote Only if bylaws specify it
Real-time online continuation of meeting Yes, under normal debate rules
No bylaw authorization at all The vote itself may be invalid

Key Recommendation

  1. Check your bylaws — do they authorize online voting?
  2. If yes, follow whatever rules they specify for the process.
  3. If your bylaws are silent, consult **Robert's Rules and consider adopting a special rule of order to govern this process properly.
Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions