Can different voting methods be used for different members on the same vote
Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Are inconsistent voting methods allowed for the same types of votes?
Consistent Voting Methods
The Short Answer
No — Robert's Rules requires that the same voting method be applied consistently to all members for a given vote. The assembly cannot use different voting methods for different members on the same question.
Key Principles
1. Equality of Members
Robert's Rules establishes that all members have equal voting rights. Using different methods for different members on the same vote would violate this fundamental principle.
2. The Assembly Controls Its Voting Method
The assembly may choose which method to use (voice vote, show of hands, ballot, etc.), but once chosen, it must be applied uniformly to all members present.
3. Standard Voting Methods
Robert's Rules recognizes several acceptable methods:
| Method | Notes |
|---|---|
| Voice (Viva Voce) | Default for most votes |
| Show of Hands | Common alternative |
| Rising Vote | Used for 2/3 vote verification |
| Ballot | Ensures secrecy; required for elections if any member demands |
| Roll Call | Records each member's vote |
| General/Unanimous Consent | For routine or uncontested matters |
What Is Allowed
- The assembly may change its voting method from one motion to the next
- Different types of business may customarily use different methods (e.g., elections by ballot, routine matters by voice)
- The chair may order a rising vote if the voice vote result is unclear
Important Caveat
If your organization's bylaws or special rules of order prescribe specific voting methods for certain situations, those rules take precedence over Robert's Rules' defaults.