Can debate happen after a motion to lay on the table is made
Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
A motion to table has been made, and we know it can't be debated. Do we have to vote immediately, or can someone object in order to have discussion?
Lay on the Table — No Debate Allowed
You are correct that Lay on the Table is not debatable under Robert's Rules. Here is how it works:
What Must Happen
Once a motion to Lay on the Table is made and seconded, the chair must immediately put it to a vote — no debate is permitted, and no one can legitimately "object" to force discussion.
Under Robert's Rules, the motion to Lay on the Table is not debatable.
The Proper Sequence
- A member makes the motion: "I move to lay the motion on the table"
- Another member seconds it
- The chair immediately calls the vote — the floor is not opened for debate
- Requires a majority vote to pass
If Someone Tries to Debate It
- The chair should rule them out of order
- Any member may also raise a Point of Order if the chair incorrectly allows debate
⚠️ Important Practical Note
If the real goal is to kill the motion, the correct motion is Postpone Indefinitely, which is debatable and allows full discussion before voting. Lay on the Table is only meant to temporarily set aside a motion for urgent business — not to permanently dispose of it.