Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


Can bylaws give the chair two votes — one as member and one to break ties

Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


Our body has 25–30 members, and our bylaws seem to give the chair two votes: one as a full voting member and a second vote to break ties. Is that how it works?

Chair's Voting Rights — A Common Bylaws Issue

This is a fairly common drafting problem in organizational bylaws. Let me help you untangle what's likely intended versus what Robert's Rules says.


What Robert's Rules Says About the Chair's Vote

Under Robert's Rules, the chair has the same voting rights as any other member — no more, no less.

However, by custom and for impartiality, the chair in most assemblies:

  • Abstains from voting on most matters to preserve the appearance of neutrality
  • May vote to break a tie (making a majority in favor)
  • May vote to create a tie (thereby defeating a motion that would otherwise pass)

This is a choice, not a separate vote — the chair is simply exercising their single member vote at a strategic moment.


The Most Likely Interpretation of Your Bylaws

Your bylaws almost certainly do not actually grant two votes. The language probably means:

The chair has full voting rights as a member AND may (also) cast a vote to break a tie

These are the same vote, just describing two scenarios for when the chair might choose to use it. This is redundant drafting, not a grant of a double vote.


Practical Recommendation

  1. In the short term: Interpret the chair as having one vote, exercised at their discretion
  2. Clarify through your assembly: If the language is truly ambiguous, the body can vote on its interpretation
  3. Fix the bylaws: At your next amendment opportunity, clean up the language to clearly state the chair has one vote as a member

⚠️ Important Caveat

If your bylaws genuinely and unambiguously grant the chair two votes, that is permissible — bylaws can supersede Robert's Rules defaults. But this would be unusual and worth correcting for clarity.

Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions