Can approved policy fill gaps not addressed in the bylaws
Asked November 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
If a power or activity is not addressed in the bylaws, can it be addressed in an approved policy?
Bylaws vs. Policy: Filling Gaps in Governance Documents
Yes, absolutely. This is actually a very common and effective governance practice. Here's how it works under Robert's Rules:
The Hierarchy of Authority
Robert's Rules establishes a clear hierarchy of governing documents:
- Applicable law (federal, state, local)
- Corporate charter / articles of incorporation
- Constitution (if separate from bylaws)
- Bylaws
- Special rules of order
- Standing rules / policies
- Parliamentary authority (e.g., Robert's Rules itself)
How Policy Fills Gaps
When bylaws are silent on a matter (neither permitting nor prohibiting something), the organization generally may address it through adopted policy or standing rules, provided:
- The policy does not contradict the bylaws
- The policy does not contradict applicable law
- The policy is properly adopted by the appropriate authority (board, membership, etc.)
- The bylaws don't reserve that power exclusively to a higher authority
Important Caveats
⚠️ Policy cannot override bylaws. It can only supplement them where gaps exist.
- If bylaws restrict something, policy cannot undo that restriction
- If bylaws require something, policy cannot waive that requirement
- Some matters are so fundamental they belong in bylaws, not policy (e.g., membership rights, officer terms)
Practical Recommendation
When drafting policy to fill a bylaw gap, consider language such as:
"In accordance with the authority granted by the bylaws, the [Board/Assembly] adopts the following policy regarding [subject]..."
This makes clear the policy operates within the bylaw framework.