Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


Can an email vote taken after a meeting substitute for a floor vote under Robert's Rules

Asked November 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


How do we navigate a situation where we had an in-person presentation, motion, and discussion but did not have enough time remaining for a vote, and also wanted to ensure all voices were heard? Two members voiced dissent by email after the meeting sent an emailed vote. One was present during the meeting; the other is a part-time member who does not attend meetings but has strong feelings. Quorum was met at the meeting during the vote. There are 16 full voting members.

Navigating a Split Meeting Vote Situation

This situation involves several distinct procedural issues. Here is each one addressed in turn.


The Core Problem: Email Voting

Under RONR, email voting is not valid unless your bylaws or special rules of order explicitly authorize it.

RONR §9 provides that a deliberative assembly may not transact business by postal mail, electronic mail, or any other means that does not involve simultaneous aural (or, for signers, visual) communication among all participants.

This means:

  • If your bylaws do not authorize email voting, the email vote has no parliamentary standing
  • The two dissenting voices submitted by email are procedurally irrelevant to the official record
  • The vote that counts is the one taken at the meeting where quorum was present

Breaking Down Your Specific Issues

1. The Meeting Vote (Where Quorum Was Met)

✅ This is your valid vote. If quorum was confirmed and a majority voted in favor, the motion carried. That is the official action of the body.

2. The Member Present Who Dissented Via Email
  • They had the opportunity to vote and voice dissent at the meeting
  • Their email dissent carries no parliamentary weight
  • However, if they voted with the majority, they may have the right to move to reconsider (RONR §37) at the next meeting
    • Only a member who voted on the prevailing side may bring reconsideration
    • This must be done at the same or next meeting
3. The Part-Time Member Who Does Not Attend Meetings

This raises a governance question you must check in your bylaws:

Question Why It Matters
Are part-time members defined as voting members? Determines whether they have standing
Does membership require meeting attendance? May affect voting rights
Do your bylaws define quorum differently? Affects vote validity

If they are a voting member who simply did not attend, that is their choice — RONR does not protect an absent member's right to vote. Members are expected to attend in order to participate.


What You Should Do Now

Step 1: Check Your Bylaws First

Look for any language authorizing:

  • Electronic or email voting
  • Absentee voting
  • Voting rights of part-time members
Step 2: If No Email Voting Authorization Exists
  • The meeting vote stands as taken
  • Document it properly in the minutes (what was decided, not the email exchange)
  • The email exchange is not part of the official record
Step 3: If There Is Genuine Controversy

If the body wants to revisit the decision out of goodwill (not parliamentary obligation), the proper path is:

  1. At the next meeting, a member who voted with the prevailing side moves to reconsider (RONR §37)
  2. OR any member may move to rescind the action (RONR §35), which requires:
    • A two-thirds vote, OR
    • A majority vote with previous notice
Step 4: Address the Inclusivity Concern Proactively

If your organization genuinely wants broader participation, the proper fix is a bylaws amendment to authorize:

  • Electronic meetings (RONR §9)
  • Email voting on specific matters
  • Or adjusted meeting structures

Practical Recommendation

The vote taken at the meeting is valid. The email responses are not official votes. The dissenting voices, while worth acknowledging in conversation, do not change the parliamentary outcome.

If leadership wants to honor those concerns, the right move is reconsideration at the next meeting — not treating the email exchange as equivalent to a floor vote.

Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions