Can a simple majority adopt a special rule that requires a two-thirds vote to rescind
Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Let's say a motion says the following: "Resolved, that a two-thirds vote is required to publish a particular type of statement. Resolved, that a two-thirds vote is required to amend or rescind this motion." This motion is a special rule of order, so it could be adopted by a majority of the whole membership instead of a two-thirds vote. Can a simple majority really adopt a rule that can only be reversed by a two-thirds majority? Can it really prevent this particular special rule from being reversed by a majority of the body?
This is an excellent and nuanced question that gets at a fundamental tension in parliamentary law.
The Short Answer
No — a simple majority cannot entrench a rule against future majorities in this way. The self-amending/self-protecting clause is essentially unenforceable under Robert's Rules.
The Core Principle: Equal Rights of Future Assemblies
Robert's Rules establishes a foundational principle that a deliberative body cannot bind its future self beyond what is authorized by the governing documents. More specifically:
A rule adopted by a majority cannot grant itself protection that exceeds what the rules themselves allow for that class of rule.
A special rule of order, under normal circumstances, requires a 2/3 vote to adopt, amend, or rescind (with notice), or a majority of the entire membership without notice. That threshold is set by Robert's Rules itself — not by the motion.
Why the Self-Protective Clause Fails
When the motion says "a 2/3 vote is required to amend or rescind this motion," it is attempting to elevate its own protection above what Robert's Rules prescribes for its class. This creates two problems:
-
The motion cannot bootstrap itself. The protection would need to have been in place before the motion was adopted to govern how it is changed. A rule cannot write its own amendment threshold at adoption.
-
Robert's Rules' rescission rules always apply. Under Robert's Rules, any motion can be rescinded or amended by the same threshold required to adopt it originally (or lower with prior notice). The assembly retains this right inherently. A simple majority rule cannot strip a future assembly of this right.
-
Hierarchy of authority. A special rule of order sits below the bylaws in the hierarchy of governing documents. It cannot grant itself bylaw-level protection. If the body wanted a 2/3 requirement to be genuinely binding, it would need to be in the bylaws.
The Practical Result
| Clause | Validity |
|---|---|
| "2/3 vote required to publish this type of statement" | ✅ Likely valid as the operative rule |
| "2/3 vote required to amend or rescind this motion" | ❌ Not enforceable — Robert's Rules'/ thresholds still apply |
A future majority could raise a Point of Order that the self-protective clause is null and void, and the chair should sustain it. That clause can simply be ignored.
How to Actually Entrench Such a Rule
If the assembly genuinely wants 2/3 protection, the proper approaches are:
- Place it in the bylaws (which require a higher threshold to amend)
- Adopt it as a bylaw provision with a proper amendment procedure specified therein
- Adopt it as a special rule with a 2/3 vote initially, which is the standard protection Robert's Rules already provides
Bottom Line
The self-protective clause is a legal nullity under Robert's Rules. The assembly cannot, by simple majority, create a rule that permanently disadvantages future majorities beyond the protections Robert's Rules already assigns to that class of rule. That power belongs to the bylaws alone.