Advertisement
Join Now | Already a member? Sign In


Can a simple majority adopt a special rule that requires a two-thirds vote to rescind

Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian


Consider a motion with two resolved clauses: first, that a two-thirds vote is required to publish a particular type of statement; second, that a two-thirds vote is required to amend or rescind the motion. Because this is a special rule of order, it can be adopted by a majority of the entire membership rather than a two-thirds vote. Can a simple majority really adopt a rule that can only be reversed by a two-thirds majority?

This is an excellent question that touches on a fundamental tension in parliamentary law. Let me address it directly.

The Short Answer

Yes, technically a simple majority can adopt such a rule — but the second resolved clause is largely redundant and does not actually change the underlying rules that would already apply.


Why This Works (and Why the Second Clause Is Mostly Unnecessary)

Special Rules of Order Already Require 2/3 to Amend or Rescind

Under Robert's Rules, special rules of order already require a 2/3 vote to amend or rescind (with notice) or a majority of the entire membership — the same threshold required to adopt them in the first place.

So the second resolved clause is essentially restating the default rule, not creating something new. It's not actually "bootstrapping" a higher threshold — that threshold already existed.


The Genuine Paradox You're Pointing To

You've identified a real philosophical tension: can a majority bind a future majority?

Robert's Rules' general answer is cautiously yes, within limits:

  • A deliberative body can adopt rules governing its future procedure
  • But a later assembly of equal or greater authority can always undo those rules by meeting the prescribed threshold
  • What an assembly cannot do is adopt a rule that makes itself permanently irrevocable — that would cross into constitutional territory beyond Robert's Rules' scope

The Important Caveat

If the second resolved clause attempted to require something higher than what Robert's Rules already prescribes for special rules — say, a three-fourths vote to rescind — that would be a more genuinely novel situation, and its validity would depend on whether the assembly's bylaws grant it authority to create such elevated thresholds.


Bottom Line

The motion as written is procedurally sound, but the second clause adds little because 2/3 is already the standard for modifying special rules of order. The real answer to your philosophical question is: majority rule always operates within a framework that the majority itself has previously established, and Robert's Rules accepts this as a legitimate feature of self-governance.

Have a parliamentary procedure question of your own? Ask the AI Parliamentarian — free.

More questions

← All questions