Can a simple majority adopt a special rule requiring two-thirds to rescind it
Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Suppose a motion reads: "Resolved, that a two-thirds vote is required to publish a particular type of statement. Resolved, that a two-thirds vote is required to amend or rescind this motion." This motion is a special rule of order, so it can be adopted by a majority of the entire membership rather than a two-thirds vote. Can a simple majority really adopt a rule that can only be reversed by a two-thirds majority? Can it really prevent future majorities from rescinding it? If the answer is no, please cite the precise authority.
This question turns on two different thresholds that are easy to blur: a simple majority (a majority of the votes cast) and a majority of the entire membership.
The Short Answer
A simple majority cannot adopt this motion at all. Both resolved clauses are rules of order, and a rule of order that supersedes the parliamentary authority must be adopted as a special rule of order. Robert's Rules requires either:
- previous notice and a two-thirds vote, or
- a vote of a majority of the entire membership.
A majority of the votes cast at a meeting is not enough, however many members attend.
If the motion is adopted by one of those two methods, it is a valid special rule of order, including the clause requiring a two-thirds vote to amend or rescind it.
The Controlling Authority
1. How special rules of order are adopted, amended and rescinded. Under Robert's Rules, special rules of order are adopted, and later amended or rescinded, by previous notice and a two-thirds vote, or by a vote of a majority of the entire membership.
2. Special rules of order supersede the parliamentary authority. Where a special rule of order conflicts with a rule in the parliamentary authority, the special rule governs. The vote needed to amend or rescind a special rule is itself a rule in the parliamentary authority.
3. Ordinary motions cannot change rules of order. A main motion adopted by a simple majority cannot override a rule of order. If the assembly tried to adopt this motion as an ordinary main motion, it would be out of order. Any later majority could also rescind such a motion by the normal vote for rescinding: a two-thirds vote, a majority vote with previous notice, or a majority of the entire membership.
Applying the Rules to Your Motion
| Clause | Adopted by Simple Majority | Adopted by Previous Notice + 2/3, or Majority of Entire Membership |
|---|---|---|
| Two-thirds vote required to publish this type of statement | Not validly adopted | Valid special rule of order |
| Two-thirds vote required to amend or rescind this motion | Not validly adopted | Valid; it displaces the default thresholds for this rule |
Can It Bind Future Majorities?
A properly adopted special rule of order binds the organization until it is amended or rescinded. That is the purpose of rules of order: they protect the assembly's procedure from being changed by whoever happens to attend a single meeting. Robert's Rules contains no provision that voids a special rule because it sets the vote needed for its own amendment.
Future majorities are not without remedy:
- Amend the bylaws. The bylaws outrank special rules of order, so a bylaw amendment adopted under the bylaws' own amendment procedure can override or remove the rule.
- Muster the two-thirds vote the rule requires.
- Raise a point of order if members believe the rule was not properly adopted, for example if a "majority" counted only those present rather than the entire membership. The chair rules, and the ruling can be appealed.
Practical Advice
An organization that wants a supermajority requirement to be protected against easy repeal should place it in the bylaws, where amendment procedures are clear to everyone. Placing it in a special rule of order works, but only if the rule was adopted by the proper vote, and the minutes should record that vote.