Can a proposal be revised before the next meeting based on member feedback
Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Can an item proposed to a club membership for review be adjusted prior to the next meeting based on member feedback before voting on it?
Amending a Proposal Before the Vote
Yes, this is generally permissible, and Robert's Rules provides several mechanisms for this. The answer depends on when and how the adjustment occurs.
Key Distinction: Who Makes the Adjustment?
1. The Maker of the Motion (Before It's Formally Pending)
If the item has been proposed but not yet formally moved and seconded at a meeting, the originator can freely revise it before introducing it. There is no parliamentary restriction on refining a proposal before it becomes a pending motion.
This is the simplest scenario — revise it before the next meeting and introduce the updated version.
2. Once the Item Is Formally Pending (at a Meeting)
Once a motion has been moved and seconded, it "belongs" to the assembly, and the maker cannot unilaterally change it without consent. Changes must go through the amendment process.
Practical Recommended Approach
If the item was introduced at a previous meeting and is coming back for a vote:
| Scenario | What To Do |
|---|---|
| Item was referred to a committee | The committee can refine it and report back a revised version |
| Item was postponed to next meeting | A member can move to amend when it comes back up |
| Item not yet formally introduced | Simply introduce the revised version |
Best Practice for This Situation
If the goal is to incorporate member feedback before the vote, the cleanest options are:
- Don't formally move it yet — gather feedback informally, revise, then introduce the polished version at the next meeting
- Refer it to a committee with instructions to incorporate feedback and report back
- Introduce it, then amend it at the meeting when the vote occurs, based on the feedback received
Important Caveat
If the organization's bylaws or special rules address how proposals are submitted, reviewed, or amended, those rules take precedence over Robert's Rules. Always check your governing documents first.