Can a prior presentation be reopened under unfinished business with no pending motion
Asked October 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Robert's Rules states that business can come before an assembly by a motion or by the presentation of a communication to the assembly. At our last meeting we had a presentation, and we would like to open it up again for additional discussion and public comment. Is it proper to place this under "Unfinished Business" even though no action was taken on the communication and there are no unresolved motions?
Placing a Previous Presentation Under "Unfinished Business"
This is a great question, and the short answer is: no, it would not be proper to place this under "Unfinished Business."
Why "Unfinished Business" Does Not Apply
Unfinished business has a specific, technical meaning under Robert's Rules. It consists of:
- Business that was pending when the previous meeting adjourned (a motion was on the floor)
- Business that was postponed to the current meeting
- Business that was on a special order for the current meeting
Since no motion was made and no action was taken on the presentation, there is nothing "unfinished" in the parliamentary sense. Placing it under that heading would be improper and could mislead members about the nature of the item.
The Proper Approach
Since this is essentially new business — reopening a topic for discussion — the correct options are:
-
Place it under "New Business" — A member may rise and introduce a main motion related to the presentation's subject matter, which then opens the floor to debate and discussion.
-
Include it as a Special Order or General Order — If advance notice is given, the item can be scheduled on the agenda for the current meeting.
-
Create a main motion to direct action — For example:
"I move that the assembly receive and discuss the presentation from the previous meeting."
An Important Consideration
Robert's Rules does not provide for open-ended discussion without a pending motion. Discussion and debate must be germane to a pending motion. If your assembly wishes to allow general public comment or discussion without a specific motion, that is a matter your assembly can accommodate by:
- Unanimous consent to allow informal discussion
- A motion to go into informal consideration
- A special rule of order permitting open discussion periods
Bottom Line
| Heading | Appropriate? | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Unfinished Business | ❌ No | No pending motion or postponed item |
| New Business | ✅ Yes | Proper place to introduce related motion |
| Special/General Orders | ✅ Yes | With advance scheduling |
The best path is to introduce it under New Business with a properly framed main motion, which then gives the assembly a legitimate basis for full discussion.