Can a parliamentarian recommend bylaw updates or changes
Asked September 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
Can a chapter parliamentarian make recommendations to update the bylaws?
Parliamentarian's Role in Bylaws Recommendations
Direct Answer
Yes — a parliamentarian can appropriately make recommendations regarding bylaw updates, but with important distinctions about how and in what capacity they do so.
The Parliamentarian's Proper Role
What a Parliamentarian MAY Do:
- Advise the board or bylaws committee on whether current bylaws conflict with Robert's Rules or are ambiguous
- Draft or suggest language when asked by the proper authority
- Identify procedural deficiencies in existing bylaws
- Serve on or advise a Bylaws Committee in a consulting capacity
- Flag provisions that are unnecessary, redundant, or contrary to parliamentary law
What a Parliamentarian Should NOT Do:
- Advocate for or against policy-based bylaw changes from the floor
- Vote on bylaw amendments (parliamentarians typically do not vote)
- Take a public position on politically contentious changes
- The parliamentarian advises on procedure and form, not organizational policy
Under Robert's Rules, the parliamentarian is a consultant who advises the presiding officer, other officers, committees, and members on procedure, and should remain impartial. A parliamentarian who is a member gives up the right to make motions, debate, and vote, except on a ballot vote.
Best Practice
Recommendations are most appropriate when:
- Referred by the chair or board — not initiated unilaterally
- Presented in writing to a Bylaws Committee
- Focused on clarity, legality, and proper form rather than policy preferences
Key Caveat
Check your organization's bylaws — some organizations define the parliamentarian's role and scope of authority specifically, which would govern over general Robert's Rules guidance.