Can a non-attending member submit email comments to sway an electronic vote
Asked November 2026 · Answered by the AI Parliamentarian
We had an in-person presentation, motion, and discussion at a meeting but ran out of time for a vote. There was also a desire to ensure all voices were heard. Two members voiced dissent by email after an emailed vote was conducted. One was present during the meeting; the other is a part-time member who does not attend meetings but has strong feelings. Quorum was met at the meeting, but no vote was held there due to high emotions and time constraints. We have 16 full voting members. Can the potentially non-voting member submit email comments to sway other voters? And what motion language would allow the vote to be conducted electronically with virtual discussion?
Navigating an Electronic Vote with Proper Procedure
This situation involves several distinct issues. Here is each one addressed in turn.
🚨 Critical Issue First: Was the Email Vote Valid?
Under Robert's Rules, email/electronic voting is not permitted unless your bylaws or applicable law specifically authorize it. (RONR §9, §45)
You need to determine immediately:
- Do your bylaws authorize electronic voting?
- Does applicable law (state nonprofit law, etc.) authorize it?
If neither exists, the email vote did not occur in a parliamentary sense, and you need to properly complete the business at a legitimate meeting.
Addressing Your Specific Questions
Question 1: The Member Who Was Present and Dissented via Email
This member had the opportunity to speak and vote at the meeting. Under Robert's Rules, once a vote is pending, the members present are the voting body. Their email dissent carries no parliamentary weight unless electronic voting is authorized.
Question 2: The Part-Time Non-Attending Member
This requires examining your bylaws carefully:
| Factor | Analysis |
|---|---|
| Is this a full voting member? | Check bylaws for membership definition |
| Did non-attendance waive their rights? | Non-attendance alone does not eliminate membership rights |
| Can they vote electronically? | Only if bylaws authorize it |
Regarding swaying votes: Any member—regardless of attendance—may communicate their views informally to other members outside of a meeting. This is not prohibited. However, formal debate and official influence occur only during properly noticed meetings. (RONR §43)
Recommended Path Forward
Step 1: Call a Properly Noticed Special or Adjourned Meeting
The cleanest solution is to adjourn the original meeting to a continued date (if still possible) or call a special meeting with proper notice. This keeps the motion alive in its exact current state.
Motion to Adjourn to a Continued Time (if the meeting is still technically in session or was recently held):
"I move that we adjourn to meet on [date/time/location or virtual platform], at which time we will resume business beginning with the vote on [motion description]."}
- Requires: second, majority vote; the time portion is debatable
Step 2: Adopt a Motion to Allow Electronic/Virtual Participation
If your bylaws do not already authorize virtual meetings, the body needs to amend its bylaws or adopt a special rule of order permitting this. For an immediate meeting, the following motion could be used:
"I move that we hold a virtual meeting via [platform] on [date] at [time] for the purpose of completing the vote on [motion], and that members participating electronically be counted for quorum and voting purposes."
⚠️ Important caveat: This motion itself may require bylaw authority to be fully valid depending on your jurisdiction and governing documents.
Step 3: Structure the Virtual Meeting Properly
Once you have a valid meeting format, structure it as follows:
1. Call to order
2. Establish quorum (all 16 members should be invited)
3. Chair announces the pending motion exactly as it was stated
4. Open floor for further debate
5. Allow the part-time member to address the body if they are a voting member
6. Call for the vote by whatever method your rules allow
Draft Motion Language
Motion to Authorize an Electronic Meeting:
"I move that the board be authorized to hold a virtual meeting via [platform] on [date] at [time] to complete action on the pending motion regarding [subject], and that this meeting be conducted under our standard rules with the modification that members may participate and vote electronically."}
Motion to Extend Debate to Include All Members:
"I move that prior to voting on [motion], each member be afforded [X] minutes to present their position, including members who were unable to attend the previous meeting."}
Regarding High Emotions
Robert's Rules offers tools specifically for this:
- Recess – A brief break to allow tempers to cool before resuming debate
- Postpone to a definite time – Delay the vote to a specific future meeting, giving members time to reflect
- Limit or extend limits of debate – A majority can agree to give each member equal, structured time to speak before the vote is called